Saturday, January 14, 2012

Should The Rams Trade Steven Jackson?



As a St. Louis Rams fan, this season was rough to say the least.  After beginning a season with such high hopes, it took only a few games before it was necessary to pull out the paper bag with eye holes cut out to hide my face so that no one would know it was me watching the games.  I found myself so embarrassed to be rooting for such a pathetic team that I sat with my finger on the channel button of the TV remote, ready to change channels when watching games alone in my living room.  I was afraid of someone walking in to see where my loyalties lie in the NFL.  While I have been humiliated to associate myself with the St. Louis Rams, I had no problems donning a Steven Jackson jersey with pride every Sunday.  In a year that Jackson further solidified himself as an all-time great running back by rushing for his seventh consecutive 1000 yard season, the Rams put together a season where they finished a neck injury to Peyton Manning away from earning the number 1 draft pick for the second time in three years.  With this track record of futility, I wonder if the Rams would ever consider trading their franchise leading rusher in hopes of starting over?

The Argument Against:

The best option for running back is still Steven Jackson.  Because of Jackson's ability to handle so much of the workload, the Rams have gotten by with retread or rookie back-ups.  Carnell (Cadillac) Williams, although injury prone, represented the highest upside back-up running back the Rams have had in recent memory, and he managed only 87 carries on the season despite an early injury which caused Jackson to miss all of one game and the better parts of two others.  There is no doubt that the loss of Steven Jackson would represent a downgrade for an offense that is already struggling at the skill positions enough to earn the second overall draft choice.  Would losing the best offensive weapon the team had really be a solution to the future of a franchise that is in desperate need for some success?  Especially with the weight of a possible relocation back to Los Angles bearing down on them, the Rams would like to win and win now.

To take pressure off the Sam Bradford.  After two seasons as the Rams quarterback, Sam Bradford has experienced two offensive coordinators with a third on the way next year.  He was the sixth most sacked quarterback in the league despite sitting out six games with an ankle injury.  It is not going out on a limb to say that Sam Bradford has had a rough start to his career.  It would be easy to say that given another couple years, the immense talent that earned him a number one overall draft choice will become evident, but Sam Bradford would be far from the first top picked quarterback to not live up to the hype.  To get rid of his best offensive weapon at this point in Bradford's career would put even more pressure on an already bruised ego.

Steven Jackson is building a Hall of Fame like Resume.  While the NFL is full of general managers who believe nothing in nostalgia, the Rams need a face of their franchise, especially now.  While Sam Bradford has the potential to be this face, Steven Jackson still plays a large part in selling tickets.  Running backs like Jackson do not come around often, and to trade a potential Hall of Famer in the middle of his streak of 1000 yard seasons could easily be the mistake that makes already disappointed Rams fans care even less about their team.  That would be a tough sell for any general manager.

The Argument For:

The shelf life of an NFL running back is short.  While this is a truth that has not been felt by St. Louis football fans, it is the brutal truth of the NFL.  Since 1999, the Rams have had a a pro bowl representative running back 7 times.  The Rams have been able to transition seamlessly between a Hall of Fame running back in Marshall Faulk to Steven Jackson.  The terrible reality is that this is the exception and definitely not the rule.  This being said, to hope that a running back entering his 9th season could maintain a high level of play is ludicrous.  Marshall Faulk, LaDainian Tomlinson, Eric Dickerson, and countless other running backs on the list of all-time rushers never ran for 1000 yards after their 8th seasons.  For the Rams to believe that Steven Jackson will follow the career arc of Emmitt Smith instead of so many other running backs who have faltered as their bodies took the beatings of the NFL is just not realistic.  To look at the future of the Rams is to look at a situation that is most likely more than one year away from contending in a weak division and even further away from being competitive in any playoff match-ups.  The reality of the situation is that Jackson will most likely not be an effective number one rusher by the time the Rams have a good enough team to fully benefit from having him in that role.

A trade could get draft picks to help build a team around Sam Bradford.  Trading Steven Jackson in the years to come will only get less return for his services.  Every season that Jackson spends trying to run through defensive players who are keying on him is another season that a potential career threatening injury could be just around the corner.  As a team, the Rams a full of holes.  With an often porous offensive line, a complete lack of play-making wide receivers unless Brandon Lloyd decides to stick around, and a defensive secondary that saw far too many practice team members suite up, the Rams are in need of so much more than one talented running back.  The market for a guy like Jackson may not be overwhelming, but for a team that is in need of young talent, this would be their best asset to trade in hopes of rebuilding with even more young talent.

Steven Jackson deserves to play for a winning team.  After watching Jackson run against the 49ers, I could not help but feel sorry for the guy.  I have never before seen a man get 1.9 yards per carry and be amazed at how talented he had to have been to get that much.  Too many times, the lack of play-makers at the wide receiver position lead to Jackson getting the football only seconds before he needed to lower his muscular shoulders in hopes of getting back to the line of scrimmage with defensive lineman hanging on him.  Between that and decisions by an offensive coordinator to look away from Jackson with his team within five yards of the end-zone, this had to be a frustrating season for the Ram's running back.  In short, this is a guy who deserves better.  Is their any doubt that if he played on a team that could get a lead, Jackson would be looking at a certain Hall of Fame career?  Imagine if he played for a team that had a quarter back and an offensive line that could stay productive and healthy.  What if he had played for a team like the Packers, Patriots, or Steelers, a team with other offensive weapons who could use a big bruising running back without having an defense keying on him on every play?  Jackson has done just about all he can for the Rams for the past eight years.  He has given up the best years of the prime of his life to play for a franchise which has not repaid him with a good team consistently enough.  It saddens me to see someone with so much talent wasting away on a team like the Rams.

No comments:

Post a Comment